|
His first attempt to overcome this obstacle
was to play the innocent: It's not said, that these men were armed, So what does the chosen one do? This silence on God's part is in contrast to Ya'aqov's
usual experience. |
The interpretation of Gustave Moreau ,1878 |
The Bible now depicts two parallel developments of Ya'aqov's
coping with his guilt and fear.
The coping on the physical level encloses the wrestling on the level of the
soul.
After his three poor attempts of evading Esav and himself
- playing innocent,
- succumbing to save only a part,
- manipulating his god,
Ya'aqov pulls himself together,
devices an effective strategy,
and turns his stealth into an asset.
His goal is no longer to evade Esav's wrath.
His goal is to uproot the enmity from Esav's heart,
According to the ancient Jewish proverb:
"Who is a hero?
The one who makes his enemy his lover ['osaeh oyevoh ohavoh']"
Not to love his enemy,
not to turn the other cheek,
but to cause his enemy to love him, is his interest!
In order to do this To see the tricks, I imagine myself to be Esav. |
Spending
the night there that night, |
The text doesn't make it clear, if what Ya'aqov says, is transmitted to the servants, and if it's transmitted, if it's just for them, or if they are supposed to say this too to Esav. What is decisive, is, that finally, after twenty years, Ya'aqov confesses, that he has wronged his brother and that he needs his forgiveness. [In my Partnership work with Jews and Arabs I often realized, that what both sides needed from each other, was just one thing: the admission that "I know, that we have wronged and hurt you terribly."] |
For he said: I will wipe (the anger from ) his face with the gift that goes ahead of my face; afterward, when I see his face, perhaps he will lift up my face! Genesis 32:21b |
But can we believe this change of heart?
What is it , that made Ya'aqov see his true interest?
Is it the fear of being wiped out?
Have all those hardships in exile made him grow?
Has he, in fact, changed?
We'll see, that the answer to this is: "No".
The story is not about the change of a pattern,
but about how to accept and cope with the pattern..
The verb 'abr, which
is the root of the word Hebrew, is
used excessively.
Everything and everybody "crosses over" the Yabboq exept for Ya'aqov. It is night. And he must be all al-one. The consonants of the river - YVQ associates those of the name Ya'aqov - YQV, thus preparing us for the process of growth, in which Ya'aqov is about to be thrown: The verb of the process - which appears nowhere else in the Bible - is A'WQ. How can we be sure, that this verb means "wrestling"? |
The gift [minkhah]
crossed over ahead of his face, but he spent the night on that night in the camp [makhanaeh]. He arose during that night, took his two wives, his two maids, and his eleven children to cross over the Yabboq crossing. He took them and brought them across the river; he brought across what belonged to him. [Gn 32:22-24] |
The process begins with
"wrestled with him"
and ends with "wrestled with him", but the subject has changed. In the beginning it was "a man", in the end it was Ya'aqov. In the middle the subject is not clear: And he saw that he could not prevail against him, Who is "he" and who is "him"? And was it really "wrestling", what they did? It is a fourth pun which makes this clear: "he embraced him", HBQ, will soon be told about Esav [Gn 33:4]. |
Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi,
who lived 200 years after Jesus and was his closest kin among the ancient Jewish Sages, suggested: "Read 'as he had wrestled with him', like a man who embraces his friend and his hand touches (or reaches ) the right hand of his friend." And Rashi, the great medieval interpreter, says that the text speaks about : someone "who is embracing and wrestling with him, ' hovqoh ve-'ovqoh', in his arms." This relation between embracing and wrestling, is best illustrated in the "Avuqah", the braided candle, over which the "Blessing of Differentiation" is spoken, when the Shabbat, the symbol of Oneness, closes, and the six days of differentiated and polarized Creation start. See pp50 2002/02/23 |
"Then he said: "Then Ya'aqov asked and said: |
It is not said, that
Ya'aqov "overcame"
the mysterious someone.
It's only said, the someone could not "prevail against him". Ya'aqov has found his match. How surprising, that he interprets this fact as his chance to truly receive the BLESSING which he thought he needed to steal. But the BLESSING is not about the right of the firstborn. It's about his pattern of stealth. He will be able from now on, to not bypass his life's challenges, but to face them face to face, and this includes his own pattern. I remember a sentence from a channeled book, called "Living with Joy": "If you have a pattern, which you repeat over and over again, don't make it wrong , for it's exactly in coping with this pattern that you grow." Ya'aqov is Israel - not because he is an ideal person, but because he wrestles with his being not ideal at all. |
"The sun rose on him as he crossed-over
Penuel, Face of God,
and he was limping on his thigh."
[Gn
32:32]
Three times "night", twice "dawn"
and now the "sun rise".
And now he too is allowed to "cross-over"
,
to "cross-over" God's Face.
But is he now whole?
Has he finally received the BLESSING???
The narrative returns to the physical scene:
[2012_01_12- How strange, that I did not pay attention to "and he was limping on his thigh", and that I skipped the following sentence altogether: "Therefore the Children of Israel do not eat the sinew that is on the socket of the thigh until this day, for he had touched the socket of Ya'aqov's thigh at the sinew.." [Gn 32:32-33] This physical metaphor serves as literary transition between the interior and the exterior scene: It has become personally relevant for me since January 2006, [see about "the groin of my joint"] ] |
Ya'aqov lifted up his eyes
and saw:
there was Esav coming, and with him, four hundred men! He divided the children among Lea, Rahel, and the two maids: he put the maids and their children first, Lea and her children behind them, and Rahel and Yosef behind them, while he himself advanced ahead of them. And he bowed low to the ground seven times, until he had come close to him, to his brother. [Gn 33:1-3] |
How come, that he is still afraid,
despite his clever campaign with the nine donating delegations? despite his prevailing in wrestling and the blessing he received? It is the beauty of this story, that it is so strikingly real! Don't be naive, as long as you have fear. Even if you have done everything to uproot the reason for your fear. |
But Ya'aqov really succeeded in uprooting the enmity
from his brother's heart!
How delightful - the description of the wrestling that had become an embrace!
But be wary! This is - not yet - the result of the wrestling!
Even if the conflict between the brothers has been solved,
the conflict in Ya'aqov's heart is not lulled by
the embrace.
Esav ran to meet
him,
he embraced him, flung himself upon his neck, and kissed him. And they wept. Then he lifted up his eyes and saw the women and the children and said: What are these to you? He said: - the children with whom God has favored your servant. Then the maids came close, they and their children, and bowed low. Then Lea and her children came close and bowed low. afterward Yosef and Rahel came close and bowed low. [Gn 33:4-7] |
The BLESSING from the mystical
"someone" was fine.
But the BLESSING he received will become valid only, if Ya'aqov can right the wrong he has done to Esav. Esav seems to have forgiven and needs no compensation. But Ya'aqov's soul will not be at peace, until he'll be allowed to return something as his BLESSING. He is pleading desperately, that Esav may take his gift. "al-na! im-na! No, please, if , please!" Yes, the text uses the strong verb patzar, used nowhere else: "And he pressed him" [the noun petzirah is an iron tool, 1.Samuel 13, 21] |
He said;
What to you is all this camp that I have met? He said: - to find favor in my lord's eyes. Esav said; I have plenty, my brother, let what is yours remain yours. Ya'aqov said: No, please! Please, if I have found favor in your eyes, then take this gift from my hand. [Gn 33:8-10a] |
For
I have, after all, seen your face, as one sees the face of God and you have been gracious to me. Please, take my BLESSING that is brought to you! for God has shown me favor - for I have everything. And he pressed him, so he took it. [Gn 33:10b-11] |
Now, everything will be wonderful
- peace and harmony for ever and ever.
But no! Not at all! To live in peace, does not demand to walk and live together. On the contrary! More often peace will prevail only when we part from each other. But why does Ya'aqov/Israel have to make excuses? Couldn't he - for once - have been honest with Esav? Of course, there is no trust yet, suspicion has not subsided. But what's more probable: Ya'aqov just cannot help it! He cannot tell Esav his true reasons. |
Then he said; |
It is Nimrod, a kind of antithesis
to Abraham, who builds Ninive
[Gn10:9-12]
Israel's fathers are cast into the image of wandering nomads. They build nothing except an altar here and there. They leave no traces of human technology except wells. Only in this moment of wholeness "building" is allowed. But significantly the place is called "Succot", which is the plural of succah, a temporary shelter against wind, rain and sun, the symbol of the Succot Festival, which celebrates the inner completion of freedom, started half a year earlier with the liberation from exterior slavery. |
|
And now?
Oh the moment of wholeness! How short-lived it is!
"Ya'aqov
came-home in wholeness
- SHALEM -
to the city of Shekhem,
which is in the land of Canaan"
[Gn33:18]
What follows is the atrocious
deceit of two of
Ya'aqov's sons,
as revenge for the rape of their sister Dina. The deceit, compared to which Ya'aqov's deceit was child's play, is perpetrated against men, women and children in the town Shekhem, today Nablous in Palestinian land. [Genesis chapter 34] "Ya'aqov's sons answered Shekhem and Hamor his father with deceit, speaking (thus) because he had defiled Dina their sister. " |
Ya'aqov knows
the consequences:
"You have stirred-up-trouble for me, making me reek among the settled-folk of the land, the Canaanites and the Perizzites! For I have menfolk few in number; they will band together against me and strike me, and I will be destroyed, I and my household!" But the Bible is not a book of history. It does not tell, how this came to pass. |
The point has already been made:
The WRESTLING with and EMBRACING of the parts we hate in us, will go on.
The BLESSING we need is that we may have the strength and power to do that.
I want to close with a close-up of Gustave Doré's interpretation
and with Rainer Maria Rilke's line from a poem I don't remember:
"Sein Wachstum ist der Tiefbesiegte von immer
Groesserem zu sein"
"His growth is in being the deeply-defeated of what
will be greater and greater."
2003_03_26
Is it by chance, that
in "Rembrandt's Drawings" I found only these two illustrations:
Ya'aqov's
interactions with the two men in his life,
the deception of his brother Esav and his separation from his uncle Lavan. |
2004_06_18
While working on "Bat-Sheva
and David" I came across this woundrous 2002 interpretation of Ya'aqov's
wrestling by John
Bradford
"Jacob Wrestling with
the Angel provides us with one of the strongest images in the show. "He interprets it instructively
telling us |
2013-11-01
It
is still early morning: 7:45 and I already got 3 "messages" with the same aim: to learn again how the frightful can be fruitful. The first message: My getting-up game in the morning includes: connecting the electricity to the TV recorder, click the order of buttons and then, while accomplishing the "jobs" of taking care of my teeth and dentures, making my bed etc. to open one of the 3 channels, to which I limit myself and choose the one which provides me with a relevant content. Today it was in 3SAT - a program about Equatorial Guinea When the Portugese invaders overran the country, the old culture seemed to have no chance, people lost their feeling of identity. A new culture spread, a mix between Africa and Europe, Yet now the people return to teach and learn their own culture. What was striking me the understanding that the indigenous people were not only violated, they were also enriched! This means: An important result of invasions and immigrations is the cross-fertilization of different cultures. The second message did not express this law of reality, but - in association with the first - I felt it: A part of my getting-up game is to draw a book from my shelf and open it blindly. Today was an exception: Borris suddenly returned from abroad after 3 months, and at his mother's place found what he had ordered long ago: the 2010 edition of "Right Use of Will", for which I had asked. When I opened blindly, it was about the Lemurians and why they attracted the dinosaurs. I remembered that many, before perishing altogether, escaped to Atlantis, where they were "received" just like the immigrants today, be it in the USA or in Israel or in Europe (recently hundreds of immigrants from Africa drowned at the Sicilian coast....). But this time, instead of being pained by all the evil, I could see that purpose of emigration-immigration: it enriches the country that is so resistant to immigrants. The third message : the article "Jacob the Immigrant" showed me an aspect of this story, this jewel in the crown of my biblical learning-teaching, of which I had never thought: If Ya'aqov would have been a good guy and stayed put in his tent with mother, father, brother, there would not have been any "Israel" up to this day. Though the lekh-lekhâ of Abraham shows, that an exterior reason for wandering is not necessary, not the plight of hunger or violence, and definitely not the need to escape the consequences of a crime as in Ya'aqov's case, and though the experiences in the hostile host-country are not much better than those in the home-country, in any case there occurs this enrichment, this fertilization, in both directions: from the invaders to the indigenous people or the immigrants to the hostile hosts and from the hosts to the immigrants or invaders. |
From
"Tru'ah" A D’var Torah for Parshat Toldot by Rabbi Seth Wax, Congregation Mt. Sinai, Brooklyn, NY
At the end of Parshat Toldot, Jacob has taken his father's blessing from his older brother, Esau, with a ruse at the urging of his mother, Rebecca. When Esau discovers the blessing has been taken by his sibling, he plots to kill him in revenge. Upon learning this, Rebecca warns Jacob to flee to Haran, to stay with her brother, Laban. She suggests that he stay with him for a few days – yamim achadim – until the fury of his brother subsides (Gen. 27:44). As we well know, these “few days” at first last seven years before extending to twenty – a significant period of time. And although Jacob meets his beloved Rachel and marries not only her but her sister Leah, giving rise to a large family, the stated intention behind Jacob's migration to Haran was to wait until his brother's temper abated, that he forget what was done, and that Isaac send for him again. Jacob is thus a refugee, a migrant, with a complex story. Fleeing danger at home for obeying his mother (and seemingly fulfilling a divinely ordained plan), Jacob creates a new life for himself in a new land, bringing his experience and expertise, enriching his extended family, his new land, and himself. ....
|
to 3 more pages, called "Ja'aqov wrestling with himself".
but on January 17,
2012, I combined their content with the first 3 pages
and used the now free space for an intervall in the documentation of
"En-JOY-ing and growing with Mika and my
Family"
between the thread with this theme along
the 365 pages of SongGame 2007,
and the merging of - now much lesser - experiences
with the "material" in K.i.s.s.-Log
2008
[the first time, I did this merging, was after a
completely new situation with Mika at Shoham in March 16-19, 2012]